A bluffer’s guide to getting elected to the Legislative Council

February sees the next election for the Legislative Council in the Isle of Man.

For those who don’t understand the Manx parliamentary system, it is what we like to call a tricameral arrangement. That sounds rather like a nice chocolate bar, but in fact means that the Manx parliament of Tynwald – and yes, it’s the oldest continuous parliament in the world – is divided up into three.

It consists of the House of Keys, which is made up of 24 popularly elected MHKs.

There is then an ‘upper chamber’ of the Legislative Council – which is made up of 10. These consist of eight who are elected by the House of Keys, plus the President of Tynwald, who is voted in by MLCs and MHKs, and the island’s Bishop, who is appointed by Lambeth Palace. None of them are elected by the public, although a few have previously been in the House of Keys. You can add to the mix the attorney general of the island, who sits ex-officio.

These two branches are meant to have the primary aim of processing legislation, but most of the MHKs tend to forget this and spend as much time as possible navel gazing and asking largely pointless questions. The latter activity is not related at all to the fact that House of Keys question time is broadcast live on a local radio station.

Once a month, the two branches join together to sit as Tynwald. Tynwald is meant to be the policy making chamber, where government’s strategies are debated, approval is sought for spending on various schemes, motions of opinion are argued over and people are appointed to sit on committees that often we have not heard of before and will not hear of again.

Tynwald sittings are broadcast in their entirety, so political grandstanding is not restricted to merely the question time section of proceedings.

Anyway, that’s a little background. The eight MLCs are ‘elected’ in two batches of four and serve for five years. Often the candidates consist of sitting members MLCs wanting to carry on, MHKs wanting to move into the upper chamber and suddenly finding out how unpopular they are with their colleagues and people we have never heard of putting their names forward. This is followed by endless failed attempts by the House of Keys to give candidates the required minimum number of votes (13 of the 24).

So, for anyone considering putting their name forward for Legislative Council next February, here are a few things you should do:

  • Don’t just clear your diary for the Tuesday when the House of Keys is due to elect the MLCs, clear all Tuesdays for the ensuing couple of months. It can take that long. (Also, if you’re successful, Tuesday is when LegCo sits, although you should have time for a good lunch.)
  • When outlining your policies, make sure to say that, in principle, you are in favour of reform of the Legislative Council so that, in future, its members are elected by the public. Don’t worry that you’ll need to back that up; your colleagues in LegCo will be able to provide plenty of reasons why, even though  they support the principle of reform, each and every specific proposal for such change always contains sufficient flaws that it must be rejected.
  • If you are a chap, try not to have a full head of hair. You’ll look out of place.
  • Do make sure you are – at least marginally – more intelligent than 50 per cent of the MHKs. That’s probably not too big a task but, while we may gripe about the fact MLCs are not popularly elected, we are grateful  on occasion, for the fact that someone who is not desperate for populist support, and who has half a brain, has intervened to offer a voice of reason.
  • Don’t let on to the above mentioned MHKs that you are more intelligent than  them until they have voted you into office. They don’t like that sort of thing. It explains why one of the brightest minds to be present in the Tynwald chamber (former clerk of Tynwald St John Bates) didn’t get voted in by MHKs when he stood to be MLC. In fairness, he’s probably coped with the disappointment reasonably well, having been called upon by parliaments around the world, including Holyrood  and Westminster, to lend his constitutional expertise. Clearly not the sort of chap MHKs wanted in the upper chamber.
  • The good news, though, is that even if you are a clever clogs, unless your intelligence is overt*, as was the case with Professor Bates, the majority of MHKs’ egos wouldn’t contemplate the possibility that you know more than them.

The four MLCs whose positions are up for grabs next year are Tony Wild, Juan Turner, Eddie Lowey and David Collister. I’m sure we all wish them well, should they choose to stand again.

*If you know what the word ‘overt’ means without having to look it up, the chances are you know more than several MHKs, so please bear this in mind.

Follow Paul Speller on Twitter: @Norbertsdad


Forget bendy buses, Segways on the seafront could lead to return of prom heyday

It’s panto time in the House of Keys… oh yes it is!

An island’s shame: the abject failure to implement disability discrimination laws

About Paul Speller

Writer, journalist, husband, dad.
Gallery | This entry was posted in Humour and humor, Isle of Man, Politics and education and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to A bluffer’s guide to getting elected to the Legislative Council

  1. Pingback: Oh no, itsn’t Act 2 of the House of Keys panto is it? (Oh yes it is) | Paul Speller

  2. Pingback: Five shocking moments in Manx politics this year | Paul Speller

  3. Cat Turner says:

    I’m really enjoying reading your stuff Paul, please keep it up! Cat

  4. Pingback: From Tulisa to Atos – Tynwald is back and we’re quaking in our boots | Paul Speller

  5. Pingback: Six tips for the Isle of Man’s newly elected Member of the House of Keys | Paul Speller

  6. Pingback: Dr Edgar Mann: a politician from the old school | Paul Speller

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s