Here is the GNUs: Isle of Man ministerial league table confirmed

Now that the final minister has been under the microscope, the league table of just who scored the top GNU rating after the first year of the new Isle of Man Government can be revealed.

To recap, GNU stands for Government of National Unity, a phrase coined by Chief Minister Allan Bell when he became the island’s leader, possibly in an attempt to explain why he chose to offer a ministerial position to someone so clearly unsuited to the role as Peter Karran.

Mr Karran’s subsequent sacking from his position as education minister, plus the constant mentioning of the Government of National Unity not acting in a particularly unified manner, means that Mr Bell has begun to distance himself from the phrase.

However, during a series of reviews of the ministerial performances by Mr Bell’s cabinet, a GNU rating was used to mark each minister out of 10.

And it can now be revealed that the joint winners were Eddie Teare – arguably Allan Bell’s closest ally, or likely to be his biggest fall guy, depending on your point of view – and Graham Cregeen, who scored so highly, in part, because he has yet to really express any opinion, having only been in his job a few weeks.

Tim Crookall, now freed from the shackles of trying to find silly things to waste taxpayers’ money on, which seemed to be his priority at the Department of Community, Culture and Leisure, is now at education. He finished bottom of the table.

I should explain that Peter Karran was excluded, mainly for the fact that he was always going to be the worst minister we’ve seen in some time. And also that he isn’t a minister any more.

Below is the league table in full. If you click on the names, it takes you through to their full review to show you how they reached their score.

1. Eddie Teare                  9/10

Graham Cregeen             9/10

3. David Anderson          7/10

David Cretney                  7/10

John Shimmin                 7/10

6. Phil Gawne                   6/10

Chris Robertshaw           6/10

Juan Watterson               6/10

9. Tim Crookall               4/10

There is now a review of the performance of Allan Bell himself.

Follow on Twitter: @Norbertsdad


Will the Government of National Unity please try to be more unified?

F for erstwhile education minister Peter Karran

How to get elected in the Isle of Man

Bell needs to ring the changes


About Paul Speller

Writer, journalist, husband, dad.
Gallery | This entry was posted in Politics and education and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Here is the GNUs: Isle of Man ministerial league table confirmed

  1. Pingback: Should action man Juan Watterson be defined as a bus klutz or by his police cuts? | Paul Speller

  2. Pingback: Is the Department of Health the right place for anyone of a sensitive disposition? | Paul Speller

  3. Pingback: Will the next year end with us having had our Phil of Gawne? (With David Icke/Atlantis conspiracy footnote) | Paul Speller

  4. Pingback: Can we bank on Eddie Teare to get the economy back on track? | Paul Speller

  5. Pingback: Cretney’s Labour roots should not be forgotten | Paul Speller

  6. Pingback: It’s time for Graham Cregeen to step out of the shadows | Paul Speller

  7. Pingback: We’re going to learn a lot about Tim Crookall in his new role as education minister | Paul Speller

  8. Pingback: Can John Shimmin prove that, politically, he’s not DED from the neck up? (With MGP update) | Paul Speller

  9. Pingback: Chris Robertshaw: Could give MHKs ants in their political pants | Paul Speller

  10. Pingback: Bell needs to ring the changes in the next year | Paul Speller

  11. Pingback: Page not found | Paul Speller

  12. Pingback: Mr Robertshaw, what guarantees can you give that your welfare escalator won’t be a stairway to heaven? | Paul Speller

  13. Pingback: Will core principles lead to bad taste for Isle of Man public – Chief Minister’s Agenda for Change assessed | Paul Speller

  14. Pingback: If the electorate gets the parliament it deserves, what have we done wrong in the Isle of Man? | Paul Speller

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s